← Records

Palmier v. Flagstone Foods, LLC

S.D. Fla. · No. 4:26-cv-10154

Full docket on CourtListener ↗

No federal docket timeline hydrated for this case yet (state-court settlements have no RECAP docket).

Our records for this case (1)

MatterTypePractice areaCourtDateValue
Flagstone Foods, LLCsource ↗
filed by The Wright Law Office, P.A. · Judge Darrin Phillip Gayles · No. 4:26-cv-10154 · 28:1332 Diversity-Fraud · view case timeline →
Comparable settlements $90M–$586M ▾
False-advertising MTD outcomes split in comparables: Cetorelli affirmed liability while Guthrie and Citizens of Humanity affirmed dismissal/defense verdicts, showing fact-specific survival odds.
Comparable settlements $90M–$586M median $117.50M · n=10
Western Union $586M · Toyota Industries $436M · Credit Glory $200M
Comparable verdict: Papaya $420M · VPX, Inc. $293M
Key precedent: Cetorelli v. Duell Action Builders — deceptive-practices claim survived and produced treble damages, showing viable path if misrepresentation is well-pled.
Main risk: Small revenue base (~$22M) limits both class size and recoverable damages; risk mirrors Guthrie-style dismissal for lack of individualized reliance proof
Rough EV model (wide — class size is the big unknown, not a prediction): $40K–$3.75M
Small sample, no defendant-specific settlement history, and no direct per-member benchmark; figures are rough extrapolations. · grounded in 10 rulings, 10 settlements, 9 verdicts
FilingFalse AdvertisingS.D. Fla.2026-08-27$90M–$586M
comparable settlements