E.D. Pa. · No. 2:26-cv-05839
Full docket on CourtListener ↗
No federal docket timeline hydrated for this case yet (state-court settlements have no RECAP docket).
| Matter | Type | Practice area | Court | Date | Value |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| NCB MANAGEMENT SERVICES, INC.source ↗ filed by Zemel Law LLC · Judge Kelley Brisbon Hodge · No. 2:26-cv-05839 · 15:1692 Fair Debt Collection Act · view case timeline → Comparable settlements –$7.40M ▾Comparable FCRA/FDCPA rulings split: Minano dismissed several FCRA furnisher claims for lack of private right of action, while Askins upheld bare statutory disclosure violations as sufficient for standing. Wallingford's failed injunction shows courts skeptical of unsupported credit-reporting claims absent concrete harm. Comparable settlements –$7.40M median $2.23M · n=8 Trader Joe's $7.40M · Xactus $2.40M · Amazon.com Inc. an $2.25M Per member (realized): ~$301 median · $102–$500 (n=2) Comparable verdict: TransUnion, LLC $40M Key precedent: Minano v. DLJ Mortgage Capital - shows FCRA furnisher claims often fail early unless properly pled under viable subsections, a likely risk for NCB. Main risk: Dismissal of core FCRA claims for lack of private right of action or insufficient factual pleading, as in Minano. This defendant: Prior filing (Price v. NCB) suggests recurring FCRA/FDCPA exposure pattern for this defendant. Rough EV model (wide — class size is the big unknown, not a prediction): $50K–$5M Small, heterogeneous comparable set; no confirmed class certification or defendant-specific settlement data, so figures are broad estimates. · grounded in 10 rulings, 8 settlements, 1 verdicts | Filing | Consumer Credit (FCRA/FDCPA) | E.D. Pa. | 2026-08-13 | –$7.40M comparable settlements |